A — Hard ban
Proven false packaging, fabrication, or governance failure. Never as live Derived.
e.g. circulation quantizes \(a_0\); free-field 13/12 attractor as prediction; lunar SWNT as proof
Status of every claim
Exactly one label
| Label | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Derived | Checked calculation from declared assumptions in a stated domain |
| Conditional | Requires a named postulate, matching hypothesis, or restricted limit |
| Open | Defined calculation or test incomplete — default for untested routes |
| Rejected | Stated derivation form failed; may return only with a new gate and new math — not by slogan |
Three buckets
Not Derived ≠ hard ban
B — Packaging dead
Old closed form failed; the physical question may return under a new gate.
e.g. scale \(a_0\sim cH_0\) as phenomenology; driven CBR-002 anisotropy
C — Reassess
Sidelined for the wrong reason; active Conditional/Open identity routes.
e.g. AQUAL-class IR; syntropy; wake; SWNT principle
Open-options rule
Do not over-lock the programme
May do anytime
- Formalize identity pillars as Conditional/Open
- Work parallel TOP / VOR / WAK / \(Q_{\mathrm{syn}}\)
- When a core gate stalls, dig harder among pillars (including winding principle)
- Use AQUAL-class IR as Conditional baseline for honest fits
Must not do
- Treat untested routes as hard-banned because recovery has not run them
- Treat UVIR-only as the only allowed research
- Force any one pillar (incl. SWNT) if math shows it is unused or wrong
- Re-publish old slogans as Derived
Authority
Authority order (highest first): Master Research Plan + Core Architecture + Recovery Plan → claim ledger → gate reports → selective publishing firewall → P1 → legacy v11 / Notion (provenance only). Git freezes win when Notion lags.